Skip to content

Operations

Dealer Commission Tracking: How Pakistani Developers Should Calculate, Accrue and Pay

Dealer commissions go wrong in three places: the model, the timing of payout, and what happens when a booking is cancelled. This guide covers all four commission models, accrual versus payout, clawbacks, quotas and disputes, with an illustrative worked example.

Most housing societies and developers in Pakistan sell a large share of their files and plots through dealers. The commission that keeps that network motivated is also one of the easiest places to lose money quietly. A commission paid on a booking that later cancels, a slab that two people read differently, or a dealer who claims a buyer another dealer introduced: each one is small, and together they add up.

The fix is mostly policy, written down before the sale, and then a ledger that applies it consistently. This guide covers the four common commission models, the difference between accrual and payout, clawbacks on cancellation, quotas, dispute prevention, and the AML and tax angles. It ends with an illustrative worked example you can adapt.

The four commission models

ModelHow it is calculatedWorks well forWatch out for
Percent of saleA fixed percentage of the booking's net priceSimple projects with similar plot valuesPaying on value that may never be collected
Fixed amount per bookingA set rupee amount per file or plot soldLaunches of open files at one priceSame reward for a 5-marla and a 1-kanal plot
Percent of amount receivedA percentage of what the buyer has actually paidLong installment plans with default riskDealers lose interest after the token
SlabDifferent rates or fixed amounts by price bandMixed inventory, premium plotsAmbiguous band edges; slabs by volume vs by value

A note on units, since examples below use them: a marla is a land unit, 1 kanal = 20 marla, and the square footage of a marla varies by scheme (many modern Punjab and Islamabad societies use 225 sq ft, older and LDA records often 272.25 sq ft). Commission is normally on price, so the marla standard only matters if your slabs are defined by size.

Two practical points apply to every model:

  • Define the base. Is it the list price, the net price after discount, or including development charges? Development charges are usually a pass-through cost, and many developers exclude them. Write it down.
  • Slab by value or by volume? A slab by booking value (higher rate on expensive plots) is different from a volume target (higher rate after the dealer sells 20 files). Both are common; they need different tracking. Treat volume targets as a separate bonus, covered below.

Accrual versus payout

These are two separate events and should be two separate records.

Accrual is when you recognize that a commission has been earned under your policy, usually at booking. In accounting terms, it creates a liability: commission expense is debited and a commission payable account for that dealer is credited.

Payout is when cash or a bank transfer actually goes to the dealer. It reduces the payable: the dealer's payable account is debited and the bank is credited.

The gap between them is where your control lives. A developer that pays the full commission the day the token is received is carrying all the cancellation risk. A developer that pays only after the buyer completes the plan will find dealers losing interest. Most land somewhere in between:

Release policyWhen the dealer gets paidRisk to developerDealer appeal
Full at bookingWhen token and down payment clearHighestHighest
Split, booking plus milestonee.g. 40% when down payment clears, 60% after the first 6 installments clearModerateGood
Proportional to collectionEach payout matches the share of price collectedLowLower; slow cash for dealer
At allotment or possessionWhen the plot is balloted or handed overLowestPoor for open-file sales

"Clears" matters. A cheque that has been deposited is not a cleared payment. Tie releases to cleared amounts, and see our guide to handling bounced cheques for what happens when one returns.

Clawback on cancellation

Bookings cancel. Buyers default (despite your best installment recovery efforts), change their minds, or fail to arrange the down payment. Your dealer agreement must answer three questions before the first sale:

  1. Is commission on a cancelled booking forfeited? Usually yes for the unpaid portion.
  2. What happens to commission already paid? Options: recover it by offsetting against the dealer's next payouts, demand a refund, or let the dealer keep a share if the developer retained a cancellation deduction from the buyer.
  3. Is there a time limit? For example, clawback applies only if cancellation happens within 12 months of booking.

The third option in question 2 is worth considering. If your cancellation and refund policy lets you retain a deduction from the buyer's refund, some developers let the dealer keep commission up to a fraction of that retained amount. It is fairer and reduces arguments, but it must be in writing.

Offset is simpler to administer than chasing refunds. It does require that your ledger shows, per dealer, what was earned, what was released, what was paid and what has been reversed. That is impossible to keep accurate across a large network in a register.

An illustrative worked example

Illustrative example with made-up figures. Not a recommendation of specific rates.

A dealer books three files in March:

  • Booking A: 5-marla plot, net price PKR 4,500,000; token and down payment received PKR 900,000
  • Booking B: 5-marla plot, net price PKR 4,500,000; received PKR 900,000
  • Booking C: 10-marla corner plot, net price PKR 9,000,000; received PKR 1,800,000

Here is what each model would produce on the day of booking:

Model and ruleABCTotal (PKR)
Percent of sale, 2%90,00090,000180,000360,000
Fixed, PKR 75,000 per booking75,00075,00075,000225,000
Percent of received, 2%18,00018,00036,00072,000
Slab: 1.5% up to PKR 5m, 2.5% above67,50067,500225,000360,000

The percent-of-received figure grows as installments arrive; if every rupee is eventually collected, it reaches the same PKR 360,000 as the percent-of-sale model. The difference is timing and who bears default risk.

Now take the percent-of-sale model with a split release: 40% when the down payment clears, 60% after the first six installments clear. In June, Booking B cancels after the buyer defaults. The dealer agreement says unpaid commission on a cancelled booking is forfeited and paid commission is recovered by offset.

MonthEventEarnedReleased for paymentPaidOwed to dealer
MarchA, B, C booked, down payments clear360,000144,0000144,000
AprilPayout––144,0000
JuneB cancelled: earned reversed, paid 36,000 to recover−90,000−36,000–−36,000
SeptemberA and C clear six installments; 60% released–162,000–126,000
SeptemberPayout, net of offset––126,0000

Total paid: PKR 270,000, which is exactly 2% of the two bookings that survived. The dealer is not overpaid for B, and nobody had to ask for money back in cash.

Quotas, targets and bonuses

Volume targets are effective and are also where most disputes start. Write rules that answer:

  • What counts as a sale? Count net bookings: bookings minus cancellations within a defined window (for example, bookings that have not cancelled within 60 days).
  • What period? Calendar month or quarter, based on booking date, not payment date.
  • What about transfers? A file transferred from one buyer to another is usually not a new sale for quota purposes.
  • Is the bonus retroactive? If a dealer crosses 20 files, does the higher rate apply to all 20 or only from the 21st? Say which.

Calculate the bonus as a separate line at period end, not by changing the rate on past bookings. It keeps each booking's commission stable and makes the bonus easy to audit.

Preventing disputes

Common cause of disputePrevention
Two dealers claim the same buyerRecord the dealer code on the booking form at the time of booking; first signed booking form wins
Rate changed mid-campaignKeep rule versions with validity dates; a booking uses the rule valid on its booking date
Discount reduced the baseState in the agreement whether commission is on list or net price
Payout amount questionedSend each dealer a monthly statement listing every booking, earned, released, paid and reversed
Commission paid in cashPay by bank transfer to an account in the dealer's or firm's name

Commission is also an area where internal fraud happens, for example a staff member colluding with a dealer on a fictitious booking. Separating who records bookings from who approves payouts is the basic control; our article on internal fraud controls in the sales office covers others.

AML and tax: what your dealer file should contain

FBR's AML/CFT regulations for DNFBPs (SRO 924(I)/2020) define "real estate agent" to include builders, real estate developers, property brokers and dealers. The regulations require DNFBPs to be registered with FBR, to conduct customer due diligence when involved in buying and selling real estate for a client, and to keep identification and transaction records for at least five years after the business relationship ends. For a developer working with a dealer network, sensible practice is to keep each dealer's CNIC, firm details, signed agreement and FBR registration evidence on file, and to pay commissions through traceable bank channels. Our AML/CFT guide for real estate agents explains the obligations in detail.

On tax, section 233 of the Income Tax Ordinance covers brokerage and commission. FBR's withholding tax rate card for tax year 2027 lists 12% for persons on the Active Taxpayers List and 24% for those not on it, for commission other than advertising and life insurance agents. Whether your organization must deduct depends on its legal status, so confirm with your tax adviser and check FBR's rate card page for the current year.

If you are staying on a spreadsheet

For a small network, a spreadsheet works if it is structured. Use three tabs:

  • Dealers: code, name, firm, CNIC, phone, bank account title, agreement date, rule applied.
  • Commission lines: one row per booking with booking number, dealer code, booking date, base amount, rule, earned, released, paid, reversed, status.
  • Payouts: date, dealer code, amount, bank reference, and which commission lines it covers.

Never overwrite a past row to "fix" a commission; add a reversal line. The comparison of CapitalEstatePK and spreadsheets covers when this stops scaling.

How CapitalEstatePK handles dealer commissions

CapitalEstatePK keeps dealer records (code, CNIC, firm, contact) and commission rules in all four models above. A rule can apply to a specific dealer, project or plot category, and rules are versioned with validity dates, so a mid-campaign change does not rewrite past bookings. When a booking is created with a dealer attached, the commission is accrued automatically and a journal entry is posted to the double-entry ledger. Payouts are recorded against the dealer and allocated to the oldest unpaid commission lines first, and a payout cannot exceed what is payable. A commissions report exports to CSV. Set your rules before the first booking, because if no rule matches, a default rate is applied.

There are limits worth knowing:

  • Commission is accrued once, when the dealer-linked booking is created. For the percent-of-received model, that means the base is what has been received at that point, typically the token and down payment.
  • Slabs are by booking value, not dealer volume. Volume bonuses need to be calculated separately.
  • The full earned amount shows as payable; split-release policies are applied by your accountant when recording partial payouts.
  • A cancellation does not automatically reverse an accrued commission, so clawbacks are recorded manually.
  • There is no dealer portal, and no withholding tax calculation on payouts.

For how commission data fits into broader software choices, see our buyer's guide to real estate software in Pakistan and our article on connecting lead management to the ERP. For where to file dealer agreements and CNIC copies, see how to digitize property records.

Put your commission rules in one place

Start a 7-day free trial of CapitalEstatePK, add two or three dealers, set up your commission rules, and book a few test files to see the accruals and the dealer ledger. Review the features and pricing, or contact us and bring your current dealer agreement; we will show you how its rules map, and where they don't.

Keep reading

Run a housing society or a building project?

See plot inventory, bookings and installment recovery in one ledger. Read about the ERP features, pricing or our Pakistan ERP guide.